At a small burger joint in the middle of the woods, the Happy Tree Friends enjoy lunch. Fungus is hard at work cooking the burgers, while Robo Star and Stacy are eating together. Robo Star tries to squirt some ketchup on their fries, but he accidentally squirts it on Stacy.
At just that moment, a happy and hungry Flare I opens the door. He sees Stacy covered in ketchup and suddenly goes into a trance. Though Robo Star and Stacy laugh about the incident, Flare I belives that she as been injured, causing him to react and in result, he see Stacy dead with blood all around her in the background as Flare I flips-out and shows his scary, evil face at the audience, now turned into Evil Flare I.
Evil Flare I jumps over to their table and flips it over, causing fries to fly everywhere. Robo Star turns his attention to Evil Flare I, but he doesn't seem too worried as he continues sipping on his drink through a straw. Evil Flare I grabs Robo Star's straw and uses it to stab him in the heart. Blood starts pouring out of the straw and, in a panic, Robo Star drinks his blood through the straw to get the blood back into his body. This doesn't work, and he soon dies.
Stacy screams and looks around the room, having lost sight of Evil Flare I. He emerges above her and shoves a ketchup bottle in one of her ears and a mustard bottle in the other.He squeezes both bottles as hard as he can, causing ketchup and mustard to pour out of her nose, killing her.
Next, Evil Flare I goes behind the grill where Fungus is standing. He grabs his by the back of the head with his screaming and shoves his face down on the burger grill, causing his to scream in anguish. Laughing, he pulls his head up and we see that the grease has melted his face onto the grill, exposing the nerves of his face. As Fungus is still screaming, Evil Flare I shoves his face back onto the grill, burning the exposing nerves of his face with his screaming.
Outside the building, Fungus is heard screaming but stops (indicating that he had died). Owly and Rablita get ready to enter. Before they can can open the door, however, the front of the building explodes, crushing the two beneat the door. Generic Tree Friends rush out, jump out, and get tossed out of the building while on fire. Back inside, Evil Flare I lands on the ground, just before the fries. Seeing a pool of Robo Star's blood, Evil Flare I grabs a fry and dips it in the blood, mistaking it for ketchup. Evil Flare I eats the fry and sighs contently upon tasting the blood.