HTF Naughty or Nice is a bonus feature in A Jolly Happy Soul .
This feature shows Santa 's nice list and naughty list (as well as a neutral list) and reveals the characters whose names appear in them, with Santa's commentary. It references all canon characters as well as some fanon ones.
Nice
These characters have been good boys and girls all year long and certainly deserve presents. Ho, ho, ho!
Naughty
Trouble-makers who deserve nothing but coal. In case you may be wondering why, I've listed the reasons why.
Lumpy - Cutting down trees, being unbelievably stupid
Nutty - Stealing candy
Disco Bear - Sexual harassment
Sniffles - Starting the war between ants and anteaters
Pop - Constantly killing his son
Lifty - Stealing
Shifty - Stealing
Lammy - Killing people and blaming it on a pickle
Flippy - Flipping out
Splendid - Killing earth's population with an atomic fart, being the worst superhero ever
Pierce - Bullying
Rip - Also flipping out
Torn - See above
Pranky - Pulling deadly annoying pranks, one of which temporarily killed me
Devious - Think about it
Ale - Flipping out also
Crafty - Stealing, seduction
Savaughn - Flipping out
Crazy - Flipping out
Shelly - Same reason as Flippy, Rip, Torn, Ale, Savaughn, and Crazy
Cryptie - Trying to capture me , and many innocent ghosts
Kam - Same reason as Flippy, Rip, Torn, Ale, Savaughn, Crazy and Shelly
Marshmallow - Same reason as Flippy, Rip, Torn, Ale, Savaughn, Kam, Crazy and Shelly
Zekey - Intentionally killing others due to him being completely feral.
Fungus - Littering, refusing to shower
Zack - Same reason as Pierce
Thirsty - Stealing from a baby and igniting the snow and killing nearly everyone.
Neutral
These I cannot quite determine. They may be good or may be bad, and I don't know what to send them for Christmas.
Cro-Marmot - Has absolutely no personality.
The Mole - He kills people, but it's excusable since he's blind.
Mr. Pickles - He's just an imaginary friend.
Truffles - Mostly a cameo.
Robo Star - He has killed, but only in his 20's state, but it pnly comes when forced to.
Britton - He's mostly a jolly soul who plays with his friends. But then put him near someone on the naughty list...
Howdy - He may act good most of the time, but he isn't when he's drunk.
Gutsy - His stunts go way over the limit. Consider him your suicide when you're near him while he does his stunts.
Sir Gron - He has pillaged villages, but that was a long time ago.
Charges - He can be happy, but he can flip out.