The Entertainer now enters the scene, carrying a small sack of candy and wearing a collar of bells around his neck and a red ball on his nose. He approaches a house and rings the doorbell. Since he is a mime, he holds out his bag of candy without saying "Trick or Treat". Unfortunately this is Elliott's house, and without hearing "Trick or Treat" he assumes no one is there, so he slams the door shut in The Entertainer's face.
The Entertainer sadly walks away, while Toothy (dressed as a witch), Wooly (dressed as the Grim Reaper and holding a scythe), and Puffy (dressed as a ghost) walk up to Elliott's house. The Entertainer, seeing his chance to get candy, runs up to the door as the others shout, "Trick or Treat!" The Entertainer holds up his bag with the others, all expecting candy.
Elliott, however, accidentally drops the candy short of their bags. As the candy lands on the ground, rats run up and quickly eat the candy. Puffy, Toothy, and Wooly shreik and run away. Unfortunately Wooly is actually carrying a real scythe, and while turning to run he cuts The Entertainer's head off.
The Entertainer's head lands on a group of pumpkins lying outside of Elliott's door. Elliott reaches down into the group of pumpkins and unwittingly picks up The Entertainer's head.
Inside Elliott's house, amidst a group of poorly carved pumpkins, The Entertainer's head is plopped down. Elliott cuts a circle in the top of The Entertainer's head and removes his brain from the hole. Elliott then drops The Entertainer's hollowed out head outside of his house. The Entertainer's head has a candle in its mouth and one of the eyes is hanging out. Before the episode ends, a rat approaches and takes the eye. As the screen goes black, a cheap paper ghost, identical to the one seen at the end of Boo Do You Think You Are?, drops down and wails.